Elevate Your Barbecue Skills with Powerful Smoke Ring Enhancers
Understanding How Smoke Ring Enhancers Work for Perfect BBQ

A smoke ring enhancer is a state-of-the-art device designed to create visually striking smoke rings while grilling, enhancing both the presentation and flavour of barbecued meats. This innovative tool not only elevates the visual appeal but also amplifies the depth of flavour, imparting the rich, smoky essence that barbecue lovers crave. The science behind smoke ring formation is intricately tied to combustion processes and smoke generation techniques. When used correctly, these enhancers ensure a continuous and controlled flow of smoke, crafting that signature ring around the meat, which is often seen as the hallmark of expertly smoked barbecue.
At its core, a smoke ring forms due to a chemical interaction between smoke and the proteins in the meat. The enhancer optimises smoke flow and circulation, guaranteeing that smoke envelops the meat evenly. This not only results in an attractive final product but also enriches the flavor experience. By facilitating deeper smoke penetration and improving cooking efficiency, a smoke ring enhancer allows both beginner and experienced grillers to achieve professional-grade barbecue results right from their own backyards.
In the vibrant and diverse landscape of barbecue culture throughout the United States, the use of a smoke ring enhancer can significantly affect how your dish is perceived. Many barbecue competitions and enthusiasts focus heavily on both the visual allure and the flavour profiles of their smoked meats, making these devices increasingly sought after by grilling aficionados. Whether you are throwing a lively cookout in Texas or enjoying a casual barbecue in California, a beautifully crafted smoke ring can elevate your dish, creating unforgettable moments with friends and family that will be cherished for years to come.
Exploring the Different Types of Smoke Ring Enhancers on the Market
The marketplace offers a broad array of smoke ring enhancers, featuring various devices tailored to accommodate distinct smoking techniques and individual preferences. Generally, these enhancers can be classified into basic attachments and more sophisticated systems designed for professional-grade barbecuing.
Basic smoke ring enhancers usually take the form of attachments that can easily be affixed to grills or smokers. These devices often encompass a chamber for igniting and smoldering wood chips, generating smoke that is directed into the cooking compartment. Such models are particularly user-friendly, making them ideal for novices. They facilitate straightforward smoke management without necessitating extensive knowledge of grilling techniques.
Conversely, advanced smoke ring enhancers may incorporate electric or automated systems, frequently featuring multiple temperature and smoke production settings that allow cooks to achieve precise results. These advanced systems are especially beneficial for dedicated barbecue enthusiasts or professionals who aspire to maintain consistent, high-quality outcomes across various cuts of meat.
Additionally, some enhancers are equipped with adjustable vents or customizable smoke intensity controls, enabling users to tailor smoke levels to match different meats and personal tastes. For instance, brisket and ribs may thrive under a robust smoke profile, while chicken might flourish with a gentler touch. This versatility makes smoke ring enhancers a worthwhile investment for anyone eager to refine their grilling skills and enhance their culinary creations.
Uncovering the Numerous Advantages of Smoke Ring Enhancers
The advantages of utilizing a smoke ring enhancer extend far beyond mere aesthetics. When effectively employed, these devices can significantly enhance the flavour, tenderness, and overall quality of barbecued meats. One of the most notable benefits is the depth of flavour that comes from evenly distributed smoke. The smoke rings that appear around the meat not only signal a well-smoked product but also indicate that the meat has absorbed a rich array of smoky flavours.
Moreover, smoke ring enhancers can drastically improve cooking efficiency. Enhanced smoke circulation allows meats to cook more uniformly, thereby minimizing the risk of overcooked edges or undercooked centers. This is particularly critical when working with larger cuts of meat, such as briskets or pork shoulders, which require prolonged cooking times to achieve ideal doneness.
For barbecue aficionados across the U.S., the striking visual appeal of a prominent smoke ring is a source of pride. Many grilling competitions and casual gatherings place a significant emphasis on presentation. A well-developed smoke ring can transform a standard meal into a visual feast, capturing the attention and admiration of your guests and leaving a lasting impression.
Furthermore, by using a smoke ring enhancer, cooks can experiment with various types of wood to create distinctive flavours. The ability to blend different smoking woods, such as hickory, mesquite, or applewood, opens the door to a multitude of flavour experiences, further enriching the barbecue journey. For those who value not just taste but also the craft of barbecuing, a smoke ring enhancer becomes an indispensable tool in their culinary toolkit.
Implementing Essential Safety Protocols When Using Smoke Ring Enhancers

Carefully Reviewing Manufacturer’s Instructions for Safe Operation
Before embarking on your culinary adventure with a smoke ring enhancer, it is crucial to become acquainted with the manufacturer’s instructions. These manuals provide vital information specific to your model, ensuring both safe operation and optimal performance. Neglecting these guidelines could lead to improper usage, potentially resulting in accidents, injuries, or damage to the device.
Understanding the various settings, features, and functionalities outlined in the manual can significantly enhance your grilling experience. For instance, some enhancers may require certain types of fuel or wood chips, while others might have specific ventilation needs. Being well-informed about these details can help you avoid common pitfalls that many inexperienced grillers face, such as unexpected flare-ups or inconsistent smoke generation.
Moreover, studying the manual can offer valuable troubleshooting tips and maintenance recommendations, which can aid in extending the lifespan of your smoke ring enhancer. In the world of barbecuing, safety and knowledge go hand in hand. Familiarizing yourself with how to operate your smoke ring enhancer empowers you to create delectable dishes while minimizing the risks associated with grilling.
Conducting Thorough Inspections for Signs of Wear or Damage
Before utilizing your smoke ring enhancer, it is essential to perform a meticulous inspection for any indications of wear or damage. This often-overlooked step is vital for ensuring both safety and performance. Careful examination of the device for cracks, loose fittings, or other forms of damage can help avert malfunctions that could compromise your overall cooking experience.
For example, a cracked chamber may lead to uneven smoke distribution or even hazardous leaks. Loose components can create unstable operation, increasing the risk of burns or fires. By allocating time to inspect your enhancer prior to each use, you not only safeguard the integrity of your food but also ensure the safety of yourself and those around you.
Routine inspections also enable you to monitor the overall condition and longevity of your device. If you notice any issues, address them promptly by repairing or replacing parts as necessary. This proactive approach improves both the safety and efficiency of your smoke ring enhancer, ensuring that every barbecue session is a successful and enjoyable one.
Achieving Optimal Performance Through Strategic Placement

The placement of your smoke ring enhancer on the grill or smoker is crucial for ensuring a safe and effective cooking process. Incorrect positioning can lead to hazards, such as flare-ups or insufficient smoke circulation, adversely affecting your grilling outcomes. It is imperative to follow the guidelines provided in the manual regarding placement to guarantee optimal smoke production and heat distribution.
When positioning the enhancer, consider the heat source and airflow patterns within your grill. Ideally, the enhancer should be situated in a spot where it can generate and deliver smoke evenly around the meat. This often involves placing it close to the heat source but not directly over it, allowing for a more controlled smoke environment.
Additionally, ensure that the enhancer is stable and secure to prevent it from tipping during use. An unsteady setup can lead to accidents, such as spilling hot wood chips or causing flare-ups. By strategically positioning your smoke ring enhancer, you can create a safer cooking atmosphere that maximizes both flavour and safety.
Utilising Protective Gear for Enhanced Safety
Grilling involves high temperatures and the potential for splatter, making it imperative to don appropriate protective gear when operating a smoke ring enhancer. Heat-resistant gloves and aprons serve as your primary defense against burns or injuries while using the device. The unpredictable nature of grilling, combined with the high temperatures involved, necessitates the use of safety equipment to ensure you can focus on crafting delicious barbecue without compromising your personal safety.
Heat-resistant gloves provide essential grip and protection, enabling you to handle hot components or adjust meat without risking burns. When it comes to aprons, choosing flame-retardant materials adds an extra layer of safety, particularly when working near open flames. This precaution can make the difference between an enjoyable grilling experience and a painful accident.
Furthermore, consider wearing closed-toe shoes and securing long hair to minimize the risk of accidents in the grilling area. Proper use of protective gear ensures that you can immerse yourself in the cooking process without worrying about potential injuries or accidents, allowing you to concentrate on achieving the perfect smoke ring and delightful flavours.
Addressing Ventilation Needs for Safety
Ventilation is often an overlooked yet critical aspect of using a smoke ring enhancer safely. Adequate airflow helps prevent the buildup of smoke and fumes, which can pose health risks in enclosed spaces. When smoking meats, especially indoors or in a garage, it is essential to ensure that your cooking area is well-ventilated to allow smoke to dissipate effectively.
When using the enhancer outdoors, choose a location that benefits from natural airflow. Positioning the grill to allow the wind to carry smoke away from your cooking space is ideal. For those utilizing an indoor smoker, consider employing exhaust fans or opening windows to maintain a safe environment.
Additionally, understanding the smoke production levels from your enhancer is crucial. Different woods or smoking methods may yield varying smoke levels, making it necessary to monitor smoke output and adjust ventilation as needed. This practice not only fosters a safer cooking environment but also enhances the overall quality of the barbecue, ensuring that flavours are not overwhelmed by excessive smoke.
Implementing Safe Operation Techniques for Successful Grilling
Mastering Temperature Management for Optimal Results
Effective temperature control is foundational when using a smoke ring enhancer safely. Maintaining appropriate cooking temperatures not only ensures that the enhancer operates efficiently but also prevents overheating risks that could lead to safety hazards. Each type of meat has specific cooking temperature requirements, and understanding these parameters can help you achieve the desired smoke ring effect while prioritizing safety.
For instance, low-and-slow smoking techniques typically require maintaining temperatures between 225°F and 250°F. These temperatures facilitate the ideal infusion of smoke flavour without overcooking or drying out the meat. Utilizing a digital thermometer can assist in monitoring the internal temperature of both the meat and the grill, providing real-time data to ensure everything remains within a safe cooking range.
Moreover, certain smoke ring enhancers come equipped with built-in temperature controls or indicators, allowing you to monitor smoke production more effectively. Failing to maintain proper temperature could lead to burnt meat or ineffective smoke production, disrupting your cooking process. Therefore, investing in a quality thermometer and consistently keeping an eye on the grill’s temperature can enhance safety while improving your overall barbecue results.
Vigilantly Monitoring Smoke Production Levels for Safety
Keeping a vigilant eye on smoke production is vital when using a smoke ring enhancer safely. Excessive smoke levels can lead to health risks, such as inhalation of harmful compounds or an overpowering smoke flavour in the meat. Understanding the right amount of smoke required for different meats is essential for striking a balance between flavour and safety.
For most cuts, a thin blue smoke is ideal for effective smoking. This type of smoke signifies that the wood is smouldering at an appropriate rate, releasing flavour without producing harmful byproducts. Conversely, thick white smoke can indicate incomplete combustion, which may impart bitter flavours and introduce undesirable chemicals into your food.
To manage smoke levels effectively, experiment with various types of wood and smoking techniques. For example, fruit woods like apple or cherry yield a milder smoke, which may be preferable for poultry, whereas hickory or mesquite can provide a more robust flavour for beef or pork. Additionally, adjusting airflow in your grill and the positioning of the smoke ring enhancer can fine-tune smoke production, leading to the perfect smoke ring while ensuring a safe cooking environment.
Avoiding Dangerous Flare-Ups While Grilling
Flare-ups can represent one of the most hazardous aspects of grilling, especially when using a smoke ring enhancer. These sudden bursts of flame typically occur due to grease or fat dripping onto the heat source, posing significant risks. To mitigate the chance of flare-ups, it is essential to use your smoke ring enhancer thoughtfully and adhere to proper cooking techniques.
One effective strategy is to monitor the fat content of the meats being prepared. Trimming excess fat can help reduce the likelihood of flare-ups while preserving flavour and moisture during cooking. Moreover, consider the placement of both the smoke ring enhancer and the meat itself. Positioning meats away from the direct heat source can decrease the chances of fat igniting and causing a flare-up.
Another technique involves controlling the grill’s temperature. By avoiding excessively high heat levels, you can lower the risk of flare-ups occurring. If a flare-up does occur, remain calm and avoid dousing it with water, as this can lead to steam burns and exacerbate the situation. Instead, use a spatula to move the meat away from the flames and allow the fire to subside naturally. Practicing these techniques will contribute to a safer grilling experience while enhancing the quality of your barbecue.
Ensuring Proper Maintenance and Cleaning of Your Smoke Ring Enhancer
Committing to Regular Cleaning Routines for Longevity
After each grilling session, dedicating time to clean your smoke ring enhancer is crucial for ensuring its longevity and safe operation. Residue buildup can impair performance, leading to inconsistent smoke distribution and potentially unsafe cooking conditions. Regular cleaning not only enhances flavour but also mitigates the risk of flare-ups caused by accumulated grease and debris.
To clean the enhancer, start by allowing it to cool completely. Once cooled, disassemble any removable components and wash them thoroughly with warm, soapy water. For stubborn residue, a soft brush or sponge can assist in scrubbing away buildup without damaging the device. After cleaning, ensure that all parts are completely dried before reassembling to prevent moisture-related issues.
In addition to routine cleaning, consider performing a deep clean at the end of the grilling season. This entails a comprehensive inspection and cleaning of all components, checking for wear, and replacing any damaged parts. This proactive approach ensures that your smoke ring enhancer remains in peak condition for years to come, delivering perfectly smoked meats every time you fire up the grill.
Conducting Regular Component Inspections for Safety
A well-maintained smoke ring enhancer is vital for effective and safe grilling. Regular inspections of all components can help identify signs of wear or damage that could compromise performance or safety. This includes checking hoses, connections, and the smoke chamber for cracks, leaks, or other potential issues.
Inspecting the components after each use allows you to catch problems early, preventing potential accidents before they arise. For instance, a small crack in the smoke chamber can lead to inefficient smoke production or hazardous smoke leaks. By routinely examining your enhancer, you can replace or repair damaged parts and keep your device functioning optimally.
Additionally, consider the overall condition of the smoke ring enhancer as it ages. Like any grilling equipment, wear and tear are unavoidable over time. By being proactive in your inspections, you can ensure that your smoke ring enhancer remains a reliable tool in your grilling arsenal for countless barbecues to come.
Implementing Smart Storage Solutions for Your Enhancer
Proper storage of your smoke ring enhancer is crucial for maintaining its condition and functionality. After cleaning and inspecting the device, store it in a dry, secure location to prevent damage from moisture, pests, or physical impacts. Ideally, keep the enhancer in a protective case or secure container to shield it from external elements that could compromise its performance.
When storing the enhancer, ensure it is completely dry to avoid rust or mould development. Additionally, consider storing it alongside other grilling accessories to guarantee you have all the necessary tools for your next barbecue session. This practice not only keeps your grilling space organized but also reduces the chances of misplacing essential components.
For those living in regions with extreme temperatures, it may be wise to bring the enhancer indoors during colder months to prevent weather-related damage. By following these straightforward storage precautions, you can extend the lifespan of your smoke ring enhancer, ensuring that it remains a dependable companion for many future cooking adventures.
Addressing Common Troubleshooting Challenges
Resolving Issues with Inconsistent Smoke Ring Formation
Encountering inconsistent smoke rings can be frustrating, especially after investing time and effort into crafting a perfectly smoked dish. This issue can arise from various factors, including uneven smoke distribution, improper temperature management, or even air circulation challenges. By addressing these concerns, you can enhance your results and improve the overall quality of your barbecued meats.
First, evaluate the positioning of your smoke ring enhancer. If it’s not correctly situated concerning the heat source, it may fail to generate smoke evenly around the meat. Experimenting with its placement can lead to improved smoke flow and more consistent smoke rings. Additionally, ensure that the wood chips or pellets used in the enhancer are fresh and of high quality, as old or damp wood can hinder smoke production.
Monitoring temperature is also a critical factor. If the grill is too hot or not hot enough, it can affect smoke ring formation. Ideally, you want to maintain a consistent temperature conducive to smoke production, typically between 225°F and 250°F. By adjusting your grill’s temperature and the position of the smoke ring enhancer, you can achieve more reliable smoke ring results.
Addressing Overheating Concerns
If your smoke ring enhancer is overheating, it poses serious safety risks and can adversely affect your cooking outcomes. Recognizing the signs of overheating is vital, as it can lead to burnt food or potentially hazardous situations. First, keep an eye on the temperature during use and be alert for any unusual fluctuations.
When an enhancer overheats, the wood inside can ignite instead of smoldering, producing harsh, acrid smoke. If this occurs, turn off the grill immediately and allow both the enhancer and grill to cool before troubleshooting. Ensure that your grill’s air intake and exhaust settings are properly configured, as improper airflow can contribute to overheating.
If you frequently encounter overheating issues, consider adjusting the quantity of fuel or wood you’re using in the enhancer. Additionally, inspect the device for any signs of damage or blockages that may impede airflow. By addressing these factors, you can maintain a safe cooking temperature and achieve the desired smoke ring results.
Identifying and Fixing Smoke Leaks
Smoke leaks in a smoke ring enhancer can lead to ineffective smoke production and pose safety risks. Identifying and resolving these leaks promptly is vital for ensuring both performance and safety during your grilling sessions. Start by inspecting all connections and seals for any signs of gaps or damage that may allow smoke to escape.
If you detect any leaks, check for loose fittings or broken components that may require replacement. Tightening connections or applying high-temperature sealant can help create a more airtight seal. Additionally, ensure that the enhancer is positioned securely on the grill to minimize the risk of movement that could lead to leaks during use.
Monitoring smoke levels and patterns during cooking can also assist in identifying potential leakage issues. If smoke escapes from unexpected areas, take the time to troubleshoot the problem before continuing with your grilling. Addressing smoke leaks not only enhances the performance of your smoke ring enhancer but also contributes to a safer grilling environment.
Achieving Even Heat Distribution for Optimal Cooking
Uneven heat distribution can significantly impact your cooking results when using a smoke ring enhancer. This issue may cause some parts of the meat to be overcooked while others remain undercooked, ultimately affecting the overall quality of your barbecue. To resolve this issue, begin by examining your grill’s burners and heat deflectors.
Adjusting the grill’s burners can help achieve a more uniform cooking temperature across the cooking surface. If using a charcoal grill, ensure that the charcoal is evenly distributed and consider utilizing a heat deflector to promote consistent heat circulation. Additionally, rotating your meat during the cooking process can ensure that it is evenly exposed to both heat and smoke.
Furthermore, consider the size and placement of the meat itself. Larger cuts may require additional attention to ensure even cooking, so positioning them correctly in relation to the heat source can make a significant difference. By implementing these strategies, you can enhance heat distribution and achieve deliciously smoked meats adorned with perfect smoke rings.
Enhancing Your Barbecue Experience with Creativity
Experimenting with Unique Flavor Combinations
One of the most exciting aspects of using a smoke ring enhancer is the opportunity to experiment with various flavours to create unique taste profiles. Different types of wood not only impart distinctive flavours but can also enhance the overall experience of barbecued dishes. For example, fruit woods like cherry or peach can add a sweetness, while robust woods like hickory or mesquite deliver deeper, more intense flavours.
Taking the time to explore various wood combinations can unlock a multitude of flavour possibilities. Mixing woods can create a more intricate smoking profile that perfectly complements specific meats. For instance, blending applewood with hickory may yield a harmonious balance of sweetness and smokiness, making it an excellent choice for pork or chicken.
Don’t hesitate to incorporate additional flavourings such as herbs, spices, or marinades into your smoking process. Brining meats in flavourful solutions can help enhance moisture and flavour during cooking. By experimenting with different combinations, you can discover new favourite profiles and elevate your barbecue experience to new heights.
Planning Unforgettable Barbecue Gatherings with Confidence
Impressing guests with flawlessly smoked meats is effortless when using a smoke ring enhancer. Whether it’s a casual family gathering or a more formal BBQ event, showcasing your barbecue skills can elevate the occasion. When hosting, consider selecting a variety of meats that highlight the capabilities of your smoke ring enhancer, such as brisket, ribs, or pork shoulder.
Additionally, prepare in advance to ensure a seamless grilling experience. Pre-seasoning your meats and having all necessary tools and ingredients ready can help you manage the grilling process efficiently. Be sure to cultivate a welcoming atmosphere by engaging with your guests while simultaneously keeping a watchful eye on the grill.
Creating a menu that includes a variety of sides and sauces to complement your smoked meats can also enhance the overall dining experience. Whether it’s traditional barbecue sides like coleslaw and baked beans or innovative creations, a well-rounded meal will leave a lasting impression on your guests. By mastering the art of barbecue with a smoke ring enhancer, you can delight your taste buds and create unforgettable memories with family and friends.
Sharing Your Barbecue Knowledge and Insights
One of the most gratifying aspects of barbecuing is sharing your knowledge and experiences with fellow enthusiasts. By educating others on the safe use of a smoke ring enhancer, you can help improve their skills and elevate their barbecue game. Consider hosting workshops or informal grilling sessions where you can demonstrate techniques and share insights into achieving the perfect smoke ring.
Social media also serves as an excellent platform for sharing tips and techniques with a broader audience. Posting photos of your beautifully smoked meats, along with helpful hints or recipes, can inspire others to try their hand at barbecuing with a smoke ring enhancer. Engaging with online barbecue communities can foster a sense of camaraderie and collective learning, as enthusiasts share ideas and experiences.
Additionally, consider creating a blog or video series dedicated to barbecue techniques. Through these channels, you can delve deeper into various aspects of barbecuing, from equipment tips to advanced smoking methods. This not only positions you as a knowledgeable resource but also allows you to connect with fellow barbecue lovers and share your passion for this cherished culinary tradition.
Exploring Advanced Smoking Techniques for Exceptional BBQ Results
As you become more proficient with your smoke ring enhancer, delving into advanced smoking techniques can elevate your barbecuing abilities to new heights. Methods such as cold smoking, reverse searing, or even incorporating sous-vide techniques can yield extraordinary results that impress even the most discerning barbecue connoisseurs.
Cold smoking is an intriguing method that infuses smoke flavour into meats without cooking them. This technique requires meticulous temperature management but can yield exceptional results for items like salmon or cheese. Pairing cold smoking techniques with a smoke ring enhancer can create a unique combination that enhances flavours.
Reverse searing is another advanced technique that involves slow-cooking a piece of meat before finishing it over high heat. This method ensures even cooking and can enhance the development of smoke rings. By mastering these advanced techniques, you can elevate your barbecue game and become the go-to grill master for friends and family.
Frequently Asked Questions About Smoke Ring Enhancers
What exactly is a smoke ring enhancer?
A smoke ring enhancer is a specialized device used in barbecuing to improve smoke distribution and create visually appealing smoke rings around meats, significantly enhancing both flavour and presentation.
What safety precautions should I observe when using a smoke ring enhancer?
To ensure the safe use of a smoke ring enhancer, read the manufacturer’s manual, check for any damage, ensure proper placement, wear protective gear, and maintain sufficient ventilation while cooking to prevent hazards.
Can I use any type of wood with a smoke ring enhancer?
Yes, various types of wood can be utilized with a smoke ring enhancer. Different woods impart distinct flavours, allowing for customization based on personal preferences and the specific type of meat being smoked.
How often should I clean my smoke ring enhancer?
It is advisable to clean your smoke ring enhancer after each use to prevent residue buildup and ensure optimal performance. Performing a comprehensive clean at the end of the grilling season is also highly recommended.
What should I do if I notice smoke leaks?
If you detect smoke leaks, inspect the enhancer for any gaps or loose fittings. Tighten connections or replace damaged parts to ensure effective smoke production and maintain safety while using the enhancer.
Is it safe to use a smoke ring enhancer indoors?
While some smoke ring enhancers are suitable for indoor use, it is essential to ensure proper ventilation to prevent smoke accumulation. Generally, it is safer to use them outdoors.
What common issues might arise when using a smoke ring enhancer?
Common issues include inconsistent smoke rings, overheating, smoke leaks, and uneven heat distribution. Identifying and addressing these problems can significantly improve your results.
How can I achieve the best smoke rings?
To achieve the finest smoke rings, maintain consistent low temperatures, ensure even smoke distribution, utilise quality wood, and adjust the enhancer and meat placement as necessary.
Can a smoke ring enhancer enhance flavour?
Absolutely, a smoke ring enhancer can significantly improve flavour by enhancing smoke penetration and allowing for a more consistent infusion of smokiness throughout the meat.
What should I consider when hosting a barbecue featuring a smoke ring enhancer?
When hosting a barbecue, plan your menu in advance, prepare meats thoroughly, engage with your guests, and ensure all grilling equipment is in peak condition for a successful smoking experience.
Connect with us on Facebook!
The Article Using a Smoke Ring Enhancer Safely: A Guide appeared first on https://pitmastersarsenal.com
The Article Smoke Ring Enhancer: A Safe Usage Guide Was Found On https://limitsofstrategy.com
The Article Smoke Ring Enhancer: Your Essential Safe Usage Guide First Appeared ON
: https://ad4sc.com
Comments are closed